RSS

Spending time with Jesus (from the gospel of Mark) “John’s baptism—was it from heaven, or from men?” Mark 11:27-12:17

16 Nov

Jesus is Baptized - Tell Me the Stories of Jesus John the Baptist

This is an important event. It began a series of six combative situations for Jesus. Both religionists and civil leaders confronted Jesus head-on, doing all they could to trap and discredit Jesus before the people so they could arrest Him and have Him killed. All the events of this section as well as the Olivet discourse (Matthew 24-25) seem to have taken place on Tuesday (cp. Matthew 22:23; Matthew 25:1; Matthew 26:1-2).

A quick reading of this section is an eye-opener into the great tragedy and problem with self-righteousness and unbelief. Jesus was very forceful in attacking self-righteousness and unbelief. He delivered a sustained attack, leaving no doubt that a person, even a religionist, who continued in self-righteousness was unworthy of God’s kingdom. Obstinate unbelief would doom any man.

(Mt 21:23-27; Mk 11:27-33; Lk 20:1-8)

Jesus was in the temple, apparently walking through one of the arcades meditating and praying. He seems to have been alone. The scene was dramatic when one pictures the background.

The temple actually had two arcades surrounding the Court of the Gentiles. They were just as films picture the arcades of the Greek and Roman eras: stately, magnificent, and awe-inspiring. There was an east arcade and a south arcade. The east arcade was known as Solomon’s porch. Several Biblical events took place in this magnificent arcade (John 10:23; Acts 3:11; Acts 5:12). It was an arcade for teaching, and Rabbis often strolled among the colonnades while teaching their pupils. The arcades were also large enough to allow large crowds to gather for classroom type instructions. Their magnificence can be imagined by picturing the stately columns which towered thirty-five feet above the ground. The arcades provided both shelter from rain and sun and an inspiring setting.

Jesus was apparently walking along in one of the two arcades when the religionists approached Him. Again, they were an official delegation from the ruling body of the Jews, that is, from the Sanhedrin. Representatives from the three major groups were there: the chief priests, the Scribes, and the elders. They were upset, infuriated, enraged. All that had happened—the triumphal entry, Jesus’ acceptance of the people’s homage and the title of Messiah, the cleansing of the temple and the disruption of the priests’ profits from those who sold and bought, the healing of the blind and lame, the worship of the children—naturally created a crisis for the ruling body. What Jesus was doing simply infuriated them and sent them into a rage. It aroused them to question: “Who does this Jesus of Nazareth think He is?” (Matthew 21:10-11).

Note that the question they asked was one of contempt, not of seeking. The question was an attempt to discredit, not to learn the truth. The question was aroused because their own position, esteem, and gain were disturbed; not because they really wanted to know if He was the Messiah. Their minds were closed and shut to His claims. They had many claims and many proofs of His Messiahship, but they wilfully ignored and denied His divine mission. They had plenty of opportunity to learn the truth, yet they would allow nothing to change them. They were gripped by obstinate unbelief

The last two days have been good for Jesus’ popularity polls. The Triumphal Entry on Sunday and the cleansing of the temple on Monday have attracted a lot of attention. It is now early Tuesday morning in the temple. The people have already gathered around Jesus. The Jewish leaders must do something. What we have here is their attempt to discredit Jesus and win back their following.

Mk 11:27-30

[MK 11:]27They arrived again in Jerusalem, and while Jesus was walking in the temple courts [teaching the people and preaching the gospel,LK] the chief priests, the teachers of the law and the elders came to him. 28“[Tell usLK] By what authority are you doing these things?” they asked. “And who gave you authority to do this?”

29Jesus replied, “I will [alsoMT,LK] ask you one question. Answer me, and I will tell you by what authority I am doing these things. 30John’s baptism—was it from heaven, or from men? Tell me!”

Right out of the blocks the Sanhedrin is in Jesus’ face. You can already tell that this is going to be a full day, packed with questions and controversies. In fact, there are more details given about this day in the life of Jesus than any other. Matthew devotes nearly one sixth of his gospel to it.

Representatives from all three “branches” of the Sanhedrin are there: Chief priests (Sadducean), teachers of the law (Pharisaic), and elders (“lay” leaders). They come with what seems to be an innocent and fair question: “By what authority are you doing these things?” After all, Jesus had just cleared out the temple the day before. In other words, he intruded into the temple mount, the jurisdiction of the Sanhedrin. Part of their job would be to oversee the proceedings during the Passover at the temple. This is especially true since the Romans are looking on from the Tower of Antonia, eager to pounce on any potential Jewish revolt. Thus, it was their job to protect both the Jewish religion and the civic peace of their people.

Ostensibly their question was reasonable and fair. But Jesus saw through their motives. They were still looking for an opportunity to trap him in his words, accuse him of blasphemy, and turn public opinion away from him. So Jesus appropriately answers their question with a question. Now that may sound to us like Jesus is trying to evade their question. But it was common in Rabbinic debates to answer a question with a question. That would not sound to them like avoidance, but like leading. It was assumed that Jesus would answer their question but that he first wanted to lead the discussion in a certain direction. In addition, the answer they give to Jesus’ question will become the answer to their own. By answering Jesus, they will get the answer they seek.

Because John the Baptist was the forerunner of Jesus, and because their message and purposes were the same, their authority would also be the same (Jn 1:19, 26-27; 3:25-30; Mt 11:7-10). So Jesus asks this counter question: Was John’s baptism from heaven or from men. In other words, was John’s authority from God or was he just out there “doing his own thing.” Jesus concentrated on John’s baptism because it epitomized his whole ministry and because it was at that point that the Jewish leaders refused to following his teaching (Lk 7:30).

In the days that followed, the representatives of the religious and political establishment descended on Jesus as He ministered in the temple, trying their best to trip Him up with their questions.

As the official guardians of the Law, the members of the Sanhedrin had both the right and the responsibility to investigate anyone who claimed to be sent by God; and that included Jesus (see Deut. 18:15-22). However, these men did not have open minds or sincere motives. They were not seeking truth; they were looking for evidence to use to destroy Him (Mark 11:18). Jesus knew what they were doing, so He countered their question with another question and exposed their hypocrisy.

Why take them all the way back to John the Baptist? For a very good reason: God does not teach us new truth if we have rejected the truth He has already revealed. This basic principle is expressed in John 7:17: “If any man is willing to do His will, he shall know of the teaching, whether it is of God, or whether I speak from Myself” (n).

“Obedience is the organ of spiritual knowledge,” F.W. Robertson said. The Jewish religious leaders had not accepted what John had taught, so why should God say anything more to them? Had they obeyed John’s message, they would have gladly submitted to Christ’s authority, for John came to present the Messiah to the nation.

The Jewish leaders were caught in a dilemma of their own making. They were not asking “What is true?” or “What is right?” but “What is safe?” This is always the approach of the hypocrite and the crowd-pleaser. It certainly was not the approach of either Jesus (Mark 12:14) or John the Baptist (Matt. 11:7-10). Jesus did not refuse to answer their question; He only refused to accept and endorse their hypocrisy. He was not being evasive; He was being honest.

Before they had opportunity to escape, He told them a parable that revealed where their sins were leading them. They had already permitted John the Baptist to be killed, but soon they would ask for the crucifixion of God’s Son!

The question, “Who gave you authority?” is a critical one. The eleventh chapter of Mark begins with an account of Jesus’ triumphal entry into Jerusalem. Jesus entered the city as a king coming to claim David’s throne, and the crowds shouted, “Hosanna! Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord!”

The following day, according to Mark, Jesus drove buyers and sellers out of the temple, overturning tables and declaring that his Father’s house was to be a house of prayer for all nations, not a den of robbers. Jesus’ actions evoked fear in the chief priests and teachers of the law, and they demanded to know, “What gives you the right to do these things?”

In the sacred precincts there were two famous cloisters, one on the east and one on the south side of the Court of the Gentiles.  The one on the east was called Solomon’s Porch.  It was a magnificent arcade made by Corinthian columns 35 feet high.  The one on the south was even more splendid.  It was called the Royal Cloister.  It was formed by four rows of white marble columns, each 6 feet in diameter and 30 feet high.  There were 162 of them.  It was common for Rabbis and teachers to stroll in these columns and to teach as they walked.  Most of the great cities of ancient times had these cloisters.  They gave shelter from the sun and the wind and the rain, and, in point of fact, it was in these places that most of the religious and philosophic teaching was done.

One of the most famous schools of ancient thought was that of the Stoics.  They received their name from the fact that Zeno, their founder, taught as he walked in the Stoa Poikile, the Painted Porch, in Athens.  The word stoa means porch or arcade and the Stoics were the school of the porch.  It was in these cloisters in the Temple that Jesus was walking and teaching.

To him there came a deputation of the chief priests and the exp00erts in the law, that is the scribes, rabbis and elders.  This was in reality a deputation from the Sanhedrin, of which these three groups formed the component parts.  They asked a most natural question.  For a private individual, all on his own, to clear the Court of the Gentiles of its accustomed and official traders was a staggering thing.  So they asked Jesus, “By what kind of authority do you act like that?”

They hoped to put Jesus into a dilemma.  If he said he was acting under his own authority they might well arrest him as a megalomaniac before he did any further damage.  If he said that he was acting on the authority of God they might well arrest him on an obvious charge of blasphemy, on the grounds that God would never give any man authority to create a disturbance in the courts of his own house.  Jesus saw quite clearly the dilemma in which they sought to involve him, and his reply put them into a dilemma which was still worse.  He said that he would answer on condition that they would answer one question for him, “Was John the Baptist’s work, in your opinion, human or divine?”

This impaled them on the horns of a dilemma.  If they said it was divine, they knew that Jesus would ask why they had stood out against it.  Worse than that-if they said it was divine, Jesus could reply that John had in fact pointed all men to him, and that therefore he was divinely attested and needed no further authority.

If these members of the Sanhedrin agreed that John’s work was divine, they would be compelled to accept Jesus as the Messiah.  On the other hand, if they said that John’s work was merely human, now that John had the added distinction of being a martyr, they knew quite well that the listening people would cause a riot.  So they were compelled to say weakly that they did not know, and thereby Jesus escaped the need to give them any answer to their question.

The whole story is a vivid example of what happens to men who will not face the truth.  They have to twist and wriggle and in the end get themselves into a position in which they are so helplessly involved that they have nothing to say.

The man who faces the truth may have the humiliation of saying that he was wrong, or the peril of standing by it, but at least the future for him is strong and bright.  The man who will not face the truth has nothing but the prospect of deeper and deeper involvement in a situation which renders him helpless and ineffective.

Consider the nature of authority for a moment. What is it and where does it come from? There are two elements to genuine authority.

  1. The first element is jurisdiction to evaluate what is true or valuable, to set the standard against which other things will be judged.
  2. The second element is power to effect outcomes and shape events. Thus, the authoritative person evaluates and accomplishes.

The authorities knew who He was claiming to be. They just rejected His claims and refused to believe. They chose the course of obstinate unbelief. They had proof upon proof, but still refused to believe.

There are two possible answers to the question about who Jesus is.

  1. Jesus could have claimed to act by His own authority, could have said the power was His own. This would have made Him an ego-maniac or a great imposter, the greatest in history. Of course, if He had claimed to act of His own authority, the authorities would have been able to discredit Him immediately and to arrest Him for causing so much havoc.
  2. Jesus could have claimed to act by the authority of God, to be of and from God. Now note: Jesus did make such a claim time and again. But if He had made it in the face of the authorities, they would have arrested Him immediately for blasphemy. They would have claimed that God would never have given orders to cause such turmoil in the temple.

Again the leaders were asking the basic question that needs to be asked by every man: Who gave Jesus His authority? Who is He: a mere man or truly the Son of God? Is He of man or of God? Is His authority of men or from within, of His very own nature as God?

By his actions, Jesus claimed the right to set Israel straight and to speak for God. Ultimately, all authority flows from God. Jesus was claiming that authority, but his enemies defiantly challenged his claim in order to reject him.

Jesus’ challengers included chief priests, teachers of the law, and elders. These three groups had long-standing authority in first century Israel.

  1. The priests held religious authority, especially with reference to the temple and its sacrifices.
  2. The teachers of the law held intellectual authority. They were interpreters of scripture and tradition.
  3. The elders held social and political authority.
  4. The Sanhedrin was headed by a high priest and had religious, civil, and criminal jurisdiction over the people.

These groups benefited from the established social order, and they had a strong interest in maintaining the status quo. Jesus’ words and actions were rightly regarded by them as a challenge.

Jesus responded with a challenge of his own, and his enemies found themselves in a quandary. If they replied that John’s baptism was from heaven, they would have to acknowledge Jesus’ divine authority. If they said John’s baptism was from men, they would anger the people, who all believed that John was a prophet from God. If they didn’t answer Jesus’ question, he wouldn’t answer theirs.

Jesus knew what the authorities were plotting. Note what He did.

First, He met them on their own ground. He said He would answer them, but they must first answer a question, then He would answer them.

Second, He formulated and asked a question that was astounding in its effect.

    It actually answered their question.

    It silenced them, for if they answered they would indict themselves.

    It ended the discussion and their questioning of Christ and immediate threat to Him.

    It revealed their obstinate unbelief and made them even more inexcusable before God (heaping wrath upon themselves).

Jesus simply asked them, “The baptism of John, was it from heaven [of God], or of men?” The question posed two choices to man.

  1. The first choice: Was John from God? If so, then Jesus was from God. Why? Because being from God, John would not lie, and John testified:
  2. The second choice: Was John a mere man? If so, then Jesus could be a mere man. But how could this ever be? If John’s and Jesus’ ministry were really of men, then how could so many changed lives and marvelous works be accounted for? This one question alone shows the absurdity and sin of unbelief, not only of unbelievers in Jesus’ day, but of unbelievers in our day as well.

Note the words, “They reasoned with themselves” (par eantois). This means they discussed their answer among themselves. They did not just reason in (en) themselves, with each left to his own thoughts. This was a planned attack against Jesus, a deliberate rejection of Jesus.

The Lord’s questioners immediately knew their predicament. If they replied that John’s ministry was of God, then Jesus would ask them why they did not believe John’s testimony about the Messiah. If they replied that John’s ministry was of men, they would arouse the people against themselves, for the people believed strongly that John was a true prophet from God.

Note how the questioners reasoned with themselves. Their concern was not to discover the truth; but to save face and protect their position, esteem, and security. They, therefore, committed a threefold sin.

  1. They deliberately denied Jesus. To confess that John was of God would force them to acknowledge Jesus. And they were not willing to confess Him. They feared the loss of all they possessed (position, power, wealth, esteem, image, security).
  2. They feared men; they were deliberately cowardly. They feared the reactions of men (abuse, ridicule, persecution).
  3. They chose expediency, to deliberately be ignorant. They feared being shamed, embarrassed, ridiculed. To confess Jesus would mean confessing they had been wrong all along. It would mean denying self completely, and doing so publicly. Most men…

    choose expediency rather than principle.

    choose to play it safe rather than to stand for the truth.

    choose to say I don’t know rather than to speak the truth.

Their attempt to trap Jesus was stymied. Seeing this, Jesus told a parable that stated his point clearly, and Mark 12:12 tells us that his enemies looked for a way to arrest him because they knew he had spoken the parable against them, but they were afraid of the crowd, so they went away.

Mt 21:25b-27 with Lk 20:6; Mk 11:32

25They discussed it among themselves and said, “If we say, ‘From heaven,’ he will ask, ‘Then why didn’t you believe him?’ 26But if we say, ‘From men’—we are afraid of the people [[that they] will stone us,LK] for they all hold that John [reallyMK] was a prophet.” 27So they answered Jesus, “We don’t know.” Then he said, “Neither will I tell you by what authority I am doing these things.”

Suddenly the hunters become the hunted. Their private discussion/ debate betrayed the fact that they were in a catch-22. No matter what they say, it will be turned against them. If they say, “John’s authority was from heaven,” then Jesus also gets his authority from the same place. What’s worse, they refused to follow John. Thus this answer would betray their blatant hypocrisy.

On the other hand, if they say, “John’s authority was from men,” they might very well get stoned on the spot. This pilgrim crowd10-17 adamantly believes in John. They were still seething over his murder by Herod. Furthermore, just two days ago, they hailed Jesus, John’s successor, king at the Triumphal Entry. If these Sanhedrin delegates turn on John (and Jesus), they might very well turn this precarious crowd against them.

So they cop out. “We don’t know,” they say. Jesus responds in kind. But notice, he didn’t say, “I don’t know” but “Neither will I tell you.” Jesus knows they’re not ignorant. They simply refuse to admit the truth. And if they refused the truth before, they are not likely to receive it now. So Jesus doesn’t waste his words. They’re not looking for an answer but an opportunity. The Master is not about to give it to them.

The authorities said, “We cannot tell.” They lied. They knew perfectly well that John’s baptism was of God. They just were not willing to run the risk of losing their position, prosperity, and security. They loved the world more than they loved God and the hope He extended toward them. Therefore, they denied, acted cowardly, and chose the route of expediency.

These unbelievers made no decision. It was tragic. Indecision and agnosticism are always tragic. They just would not be convinced of the truth. It was not that they could not be convinced, but they would not. Such obstinate unbelief seldom, if ever, sees the truth of Christ. Even if Christ openly revealed the truth to them, they would reject.

 
Leave a comment

Posted by on November 16, 2026 in Mark

 

Leave a Reply